Taekwondo v Judo: Stop Someone from Throwing You



The above shows a video setting up a shoulder throw, and in the second part, the defence against the throw by manipulating hip placement and therefore changing the proximity between attacker and 'defender'.

I was never formally trained in this skill.

Yep, I never received training from my first martial art nor taekwondo on how to stop a throw from being executed. I was taught how to effect the throw, and how to breakfall. The throw we learned possibly wasn't covered in such detail - no wonder we always seem to resort to muscling through it. But we didn't ever think it was an option to disrupt the throw except for maybe trying to pull away with the body or pushing forward with the arms.

Let that admission sink in while you look at what is otherwise a fairly detailed video on how the throw and the defence works, and how simple both are. It really is fairly simple.

Amongst various ideas JDK presents - one key aspect of our training is this ... if we teach a technique, we should at minimum include at least one defence to that technique. JDK's approach typically extrapolates from this to then include various tactics that work 'either side.' These mitigate or disrupt the attacker, and then plug back into standard tactical responses. In this instance, when we introduce the hip throw at Dosan, we should eventually teach the defence to those throws; and we eventually see this as we look at the first initial open palm tension press from Yulgok.

To be clear, the tension press is an excellent rank appropriate time for such a tactic to occur in our syllabus. But also to be clear, once a person learns this skill, it really ceases to be Yulgok's tension press anymore. You can shove the opponent's hip using your hand, your own hip, a knee, or forearm. It is more than one technique.

I guess at one point you might ask - who taught you this and how can you identify this as Taekwondo? Well, if you want to know, a couple of very clever and highly trained Bujinkan associates of mine were keen for me to understand the structural balance of a body. These friends performed and showed us several very funky takedowns over many years - both unarmed and with weapons. They never did say, hey, do this with only this technique or only our sequence. It was never about limiting it to any one thing. So as I assimilate the concept to manipulate the skeletal structure, this was like a 'gift' from one system to another; no strings attached.

When that happened, I then make sense of it within the framework of Taekwondo. This means I plug it back into the traditional forms structure, then include it as part of our skillset to be taught and to be drilled, and then cook up some clickbait title for a blog post. If you really want to know, ours is like a 'painting by numbers' approach - and is totally different to how it was initially shared with me.

My hope is you appreciate my candor to see the essence of hardstyle training. That indeed we can learn skills that help round our own skillset, and help grow our art. When you can see it this way and if you agree that it doesn't rob us of what makes us who we are, send me a message to say hi.

Cheers,

Colin

More information on my Bujinkan friends ...

Bujinkan Shibu Agoge Group (25/3 Forward Road East Victoria Park) aspires to provide the best opportunity for its students and the community to train as both students and teachers so we can embody an ageless philosophy of theory and practice of the Martial Arts. We wish to do no harm, cause no harm and live in harmony. Treat others as you would like to be treated with tolerance, respect and a good heart. Walk through life with an immovable heart, be true to yourself, be honest with yourself and give more back to the Community then the Community gives you.
Dojo Cho Andrew Netes

--
[ Traditional Taekwondo Perth | Testimonials | YouTube | Subscribe | Sitemap ]
Please support us by liking our Traditional Taekwondo Blog's FB page click here
How does one get a mention on Traditional Taekwondo Perth? click here

    Come play with us ...

  • Make basic blocks part of an indispensable close quarter toolkit!
  • Breathe life into your line drill.
  • Integrate easy throws into a hard style syllabus.
  • Endow simple kicks with (more) stopping power.
  • Tap into martial philosophy & etiquette to get you into the zone.
  • Taekwondo pattern applications show the form is not there to limit you!
  • We welcome all styles, all ranks, and especially welcome open-minded practitioners.
  • Happy to also ditch training and just hang out.

  • We are located in Perth, Western Australia. But if you can't make it to us ...
    Travel itinerary for our black belts in 2019 include but not limited to:
    USA, Melbourne, Singapore, Manila, and Norway. Please inquire.

    To avoid embarrassment, please do not inquire about certification through JDK.

Comments

Popular Posts