I train Traditional Taekwondo in a small garage in Perth, Western Australia. When I say 'Taekwondo' I really mean I continue an 'American Karate' lineage, which was what I was eventually told I was learning when I first started in the US.
Some practitioners know me for a limited number of application videos I've shared online (both through The Study of Taekwondo FaceBook Group and YouTube), my focus on striking post training, and an old blog (this one) which has a training diary of sorts - of wildly varying quality covering fundamental skills and concepts of training.
Observant practitioners would have noticed I often emphasize that early Taekwondo, whilst having strong links to Japanese Karate, does not need to feel inferior because of such beginnings. My argument is that Japanese Karate has its own share of political baggage. So while some might get defensive about Taekwondo's connection to Japanese Karate, Taekwondo is really an excellent opportunity for practitioners to define their own martial path.
My school is called Joong Do Kwan, or School of the Middle Way. I tell people we are the point in the middle, drawing from older styles and influences, but also benefitting from modern innovations and developments. While the name pays homage to the original Chung Do Kwan, it directly relates to the training I received in the Southwest USA in the early to mid 1990s.
It was during that time I went to Dallas to attend college at Southern Methodist University. SMU is a private university situated in a very nice part of the world. I arrived in 1991 already a black belt from an eclectic Chinese/Korean style, and it didn't take me long before I noticed a small photocopied martial arts flyer stuck on a noticeboard at the gym.
In no time, I was a regular in the SMU Martial Arts Club. But there were huge differences in the training from where I was schooled in Asia. To say there was a culture shock and I had to adjust would be an understatement.
Firstly, I was welcomed warmly. You would find it hard to get past the door in Asia if you came from a different martial art school. If you did manage to join the group, you'd be considered an outsider, distrusted until you've proven your loyalty and worth; a process that could take many years. In Dallas, even from the outset, everyone was kind enough to talk with me, help me through initial sessions, were super courteous, and did not hesitate to invite me to join them for a sandwich at the local deli after training.
Next, I was amazed at the amount of presentation, discussion, and opinions shared throughout the session. When I trained in Asia, no one dared speak. Even my master would speak sparingly. When he did speak, it was more like a grunt cajoling us to go at it harder, or to jump higher, or to do something faster. At SMU in contrast, you could expect anything from incisive observations to a discourse of techniques by Sensei Bryan Robbins. Mr Robbins was a tenured physical education professor and ex-Olympic coach; and was comfortable and extremely experienced teaching all levels of practitioners on how to perform certain techniques, what difficulties you might experience whilst doing it, how to land it successfully, and their accompanying applications.
I remember being astounded by this 'chatter'. But as I turned my listening ears on, I found that much of what was being discussed matched a lot of the non-verbalised insight I had from my own experience. I soon relied on this information for my own learning and found it was a great way to share experience. I even felt beginners had good insight to offer when discussing their own experiences learning techniques.
The last major difference I noticed was how much difficulty I was having sparring the other black belts. It's not to say we didn't spar back in Asia. Nor is it to say we didn't spar hard against each other. But on so many levels I was outmatched and outgunned, and often by people I initially felt could not be faster or more durable than I was at the time.
SMU Martial Arts Club was a curious place. The gathering on Saturdays just didn't compute to my Asian brain. I was told by my instructor that the club hosted various black belts from other styles, and whilst we start off with regular warmups, basic drills, and self defence applications, when we proceed to work on patterns, each group then breaks off and practices their own patterns by themselves. So while I was learning Chon-ji for instance, there would be those performing patterns from Wado Ryu, Kempo, Shotokan and sometimes patterns from Chinese stylists.
Then we would regroup and spar everyone. It was this part of the class which made the club one of the best venues a black belt could hope to train at.
My growing conundrum in regard to sparring was that some of the best fighters in the club were also those instructors who would stress the importance of technical precision and patterns. The level of detail they wanted was exacting. So much so I thought there were times when I felt discussions stopped us from putting in the repetitions I was used to back in Asia.
|Proctor Dojo circa 1990 - before I joined it, and before I widened the hole in the wall to the left and outside of this picture.|
For instance, whilst performing line drills of basic blocks, who would be told to pay attention to the tilt of the head, the raising of the chambering arm, the flight path of the block, the height of the blocking arm, the pull back of the chambering hand, the stance, and the breath out.
Additionally, this applied to kicks too. I remember having to 'relearn' how to throw a roundhouse kick at short range. By relearn, I mean I'd never had to do a short range roundhouse before. So I had to listen to the emphasis on kicking at the horizon, the spinning of the support foot, the rotation of the hips, the attitude of the foot, the guarding hands, the snap back, the compression of the body, the re-chambering snap of the kick, and the reformation back into a defensive stance.
While at some point I believed this information to be an overkill, I eventually took a leap of faith and figured it a necessary part of the training I needed. I also supplemented in-class training with my own reading and research, and sought to remember and explore every little bit of information that was offered by my instructors.
And if you were interested, there wasn't any shortage of information available. Black belts spent an inordinate amount of time training, and not just training in unarmed fighting. You could see black belts after class going onto mats to do groundwork. Monthly you'd see a group go train kobudo for several hours in the afternoon. Not to mention right after hard style, you can go train soft style Aikido also led by my Taekwondo instructor. Every so often, you could also drive to other schools to visit gradings or competitions. Given black belts train free, SMU under the Southwest Taekwondo Association as it was called then was your all-you-can-eat buffet, if you so desired.
Some black belts would additionally go to a by-invitation-only dojo led by high-level and well respected Karate instructor Sensei Michael Proctor. You might call these sessions a fight club and you wouldn't be too far off. Over the course of two hours all you do is fight. That's three minutes on and one minute off. The rules governing applicable techniques centred around the idea that it's okay to hurt but not to injure. Meaning, you could go for the knees or groin but you control yourself so your opponent walks out of training on his two feet. 'Control' doesn't mean that strikes aren't going to land hard on other areas. The first time I fought there, my nose was bloodied and my nerve endings were screaming at me. I was battered and bruised, kicked into the plywood wall, and was literally brought to the brink of tears.
Close to the end of my time at SMU, I recall a conversation between several black belts after training one day. This one black belt was talking about how he visited a Kyokushin Karate training session, and was chuckling about how tough these guys were. He said they demonstrated how they could break baseball bats by kicking them with their shins. And then matter-of-factly said they're really tough, but when they sparred, they just couldn't touch him. The reason? They weren't as well trained as our group.
I kept quiet about my surprise but I was secretly a little proud. Proud because it had taken me several years and a lot of time and effort to acquire what I felt were pretty amazing skills. And it seems such skills compared favourably against other serious stylists.
But imagine my mixed emotions to hear from not one but several senior instructors that sparring is not the be-all-and-end-all of martial arts; that if you're good at sparring, all that means is that you're good at sparring. What does such conflicting information mean to my limited young black belt brain?
When I look back at the training at SMU, it seemed like it was not one class, but two classes. You've got the beginner or coloured belt program, and throughout the first bit of training you'd be put through the paces and required to line drill the various basics. We'd do a couple of basic punches, sometimes combining fundamental blocks and punches. Then several basic kicks like the front kick, front leg and back leg roundhouse kicks, a side kick, and maybe a back thrust kick. Very little, if any, 'extreme' or aerial techniques were practiced.
Then we'd all train as a group and work on some 'self defence' drills, which comprised of blocks, counters or takedowns. The black belts would often choose to work amongst themselves, and would run the prescribed sequences before varying it or adlibbing. It was at this point where the class became a mad skunk works between various stylists.
So the question could be asked what was it that we were really practicing? I was taught Taekwondo forms, but the training we got would challenge every one there - whether you be a Taekwondo or a non-Taekwondo practitioner. Does this mean that the style only gets you so far? And then afterward becomes a launchpad from which you embark from?
When I finally got good at sparring, I felt unstoppable; I no longer had the fear that plagued me when I started. Not because it wasn't painful - I had become desensitised to this kind of pain, and I knew most of my partners had excellent control. Without fear, I could see that our sparring could be described as a high-level transaction. It was like both fighters were testing their knowledge against the other, and these concepts fed our insight into fundamentals.
Taking this all in, my aim with Joong Do Kwan has not been to merely replicate the conditions found in SMU. My emphasis has been to unify our training using the Taekwondo pattern set as a core curriculum; this was not something that might have worked well in that club setting because of the range of stylists. But using the patterns-as-syllabus has allowed me to seed that intense but brilliant exchange throughout our present training.
|It's been decades - but I still wear the patch and feel|
great loyalty to AKATO, GM Keith Yates,
Sensei Bryan Robbins, and Sensei Mike Proctor.
Some would be surprised to know I have also de-emphasized sparring as a training tool, favouring a range of sensitivity drills, traditional training tools, close quarter work, 'self defence' sequences and scenarios to build up all round skills. In my mind, this complements the pattern-as-syllabus approach, and makes for more well-rounded practitioners.
This article was first submitted to Totally Taekwondo in April 2016 and published 22 January 2017.
- July 18 - Inspirational messages that fall short of reality
- July 24 - Why do we share our martial arts and open ourselves up to criticism?
- July 25 - What role does TKD have in a post 9/11 world?
- This Day in History 1991 Welcomes the Token Asian BB to SMU Martial Arts Club
- Australasian Taekwondo Magazine Interview
- GM Keith Yates presents Colin Wee with 2016 AKaTo Instructor of the Year Award
- What was your worst experience in Martial Arts?
- 2016 Update
- My Work as a Curator of a Taekwondo System
- Personal Reflections
- Black Belts Start Young and Dumb
[Taekwondo Techniques | Subscribe | FAQs | Sitemap | FB]
Please support us by liking our FaceBook page click here